On behalf of the New Jersey Business & Industry Association (NJBIA), we respectfully oppose A-5607.
NJBIA supports responsible innovation and meaningful consumer privacy protections. However, A-5607 creates additional regulatory requirements for chatbot providers that raise concerns about duplicative privacy standards, conflicting legal obligations, and unnecessary litigation.
First, NJBIA opposes the bill’s inclusion of a private right of action. Section 5(c) allows individuals to bring civil actions against chatbot providers. Individuals may seek damages of at least $5,000 per violation, along with attorney fees and court costs, creating significant potential liability for chatbot providers that disincentivizes companies from entering the New Jersey market. Enforcement should remain within the Division of Consumer Affairs in the Attorney General's office rather than creating an additional avenue for private, potentially frivolous, lawsuits.
Second, New Jersey’s Data Privacy Act of 2023 (P.L. 2023, c. 266) already establishes a framework for protecting consumer data, including specific requirements governing sensitive data and consumer consent. The existing law empowers consumers to make informed decisions about their data and consumer experiences, including exercising their rights to opt out where applicable. NJBIA believes these existing protections should serve as the foundation for privacy policy in New Jersey. Adding another layer of privacy definitions, consent requirements, and compliance obligations specifically for chatbot providers risks creating inconsistent standards that conflict with the New Jersey's existing legal framework.
Finally, A-5607’s affirmative-consent requirements raise questions about the assumptions underlying the bill. Requiring users to provide separate, affirmative consent for certain activities appears to assume that consumers may not understand when they are interacting with generative AI or how the technology operates. NJBIA supports clear and transparent disclosures that help consumers understand the technology they are using and make informed decisions. However, these objectives should be pursued in a manner that complements existing law rather than imposing a separate and potentially conflicting regulatory structure on a rapidly evolving technology.
New Jersey should continue to protect consumers while maintaining a clear, consistent, and predictable regulatory environment that allows responsible AI development and deployment to grow. Rather than layering new requirements onto existing privacy law and exposing businesses to additional private litigation, the State should build upon its established framework and ensure that any additional protections are appropriately tailored.
For these reasons, NJBIA opposes A-5607. Thank you for your time and consideration.
It is for these reasons that we oppose A-5607.