By most accounts, Alpha Generation is a remarkable energy success story in New Jersey.
It is the owner and operator of the largest fleet of power plants in the state, while also the cleanest and most efficient, compromising a total of 4,000 megawatts of baseload, mid-merit and peaking power generation.
In other words, it has helped New Jersey to be ahead of the pack in its economy-wide transition from the dirtiest fuels (i.e. no more coal plants) to a cleaner energy future.
All of which is why testimony from Liam Baker, Senior Vice President of Regulatory Affairs for AlphaGen to state regulators was so concerning on Thursday.
The New Jersey Department of Environmental Protection and Board of Public Utilities (BPU) held a joint hearing to discuss the price of Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI) allowances.
New Jersey is a participant in RGGI, the multi-state, cap-and-invest program designed to reduce carbon dioxide (CO₂) emissions from the power sector.
But as a result of RGGI policies, New Jersey ratepayers are now paying much more because of the state’s membership in the program, and the state’s air quality is worsening – all while ahead-of-the-curve companies like AlphaGen are struggling to compete.
While applauding the Sherrill administration for hosting the hearing at a time of great energy affordability challenges, the message from Baker was clear: RGGI, in its current form, is working against New Jersey on multiple fronts.
“Unfortunately, New Jersey’s ability to deliver the electricity its people need at an affordable price is directly impacted by high RGGI clearing prices,” Baker said.
“Because these costs must be included in the price of power, we are, collectively, at a significant competitive disadvantage to coal-fueled and otherwise less efficient, and higher emitting, resources in upwind states such as Pennsylvania, West Virginia and Ohio – states that are not part of RGGI.”
PEAK LEAKAGE
As Baker explained, this is a phenomenon called “leakage.”
By being a part of RGGI, New Jersey power plants must buy allowances for their CO₂ emissions. It adds to their operating costs and, subsequently, the cost to ratepayers.
The prices for those allowances have gone up exponentially since the Garden State rejoined RGGI in 2020.
Conversely, neighboring states that are not part of RGGI (like Pennsylvania, Ohio, and West Virginia) do not face the same carbon pricing requirements for their fossil-fuel or coal-fired generators.
And because electricity is dispatched across state lines based on the cheapest available cost, power demand "leaks" away from cleaner or compliant in-state generators to dirtier out-of-state plants.
Which is completely antithetical to why New Jersey is in RGGI in the first place.
“Not only does this raise costs for New Jerseyans, but it simultaneously undermines RGGI’s greenhouse gas reduction goals by incentivizing dirtier fuels in states that are not members of RGGI - and have no intention of ever joining,” Baker said.
“Consequently, our cleaner New Jersey power plants are forced to run less than the ostensibly ‘cheaper’ upwind and higher emitting power plants in those non-RGGI states.
“In causing these cleaner plants to run less and the higher emitting and less efficient plants in upwind states to run more, RGGI has inadvertently led to New Jersey suffering from millions of tons of increased pollution every year,” he added.
RETHINKING RGGI
NJBIA has also warned state regulators of the unintended consequences of the state being a part of RGGI.
The association launched a “Rethink RGGI” awareness campaign in June to promote a potential policy solution addressing the state’s current economic and environmental challenges of participating in RGGI, with auction rates now approaching $40 per ton.
Conceding the unlikely political realities of New Jersey making a clean break from RGGI, NJBIA’s solution is to eliminate the RGGI auction allowance price and replace it with a $7-per-ton allowance charge.
NJBIA Deputy Chief Government Affairs Officer Ray Cantor said this change could annually save New Jersey consumers $279 million, provide $135 million to the state for ratepayer relief or reinvestment, and also reduce carbon emissions by 5 tons.
Assemblyman Wayne D’Angelo (D-14) has also proposed similar legislation.
“Adding to New Jersey’s affordability issue for increased climate pollution is simply not a winning or sustainable formula,” Baker said.
FUTURE INVESTMENT CHALLENGES
If New Jersey stays the course in the RGGI, without changes, the issue may get worse.
Separately, the state DEP is proposing a 90% reduction in allowances from natural gas plants over the next 10 years at a time of increased energy demand.
NJBIA Deputy Chief Government Affairs Officer Ray Cantor questioned how DEP could seek such a mandate at a time of capacity shortage for New Jersey, continuing high energy demands, and no viable replacement of clean energy.
“Governor Sherrill has called for the modernization of gas plants, but no investor will upgrade their plants to stay online when RGGI makes them non-competitive with other sources and is calling for them to reduce emissions to an extent where they can no longer operate,” Cantor said.
“RGGI can’t just operate in a vacuum. It must be reevaluated, re-thought, in the context of the region, the need for capacity, the competition from non-RGGI states, and growing demand for energy.”
And as for AlphaGen’s ask of the Sherrill administration?
“That New Jersey reconsider the impacts of the very high recent clearing prices on the cost of our domestic energy supply, the impacts on consumers and, most importantly, the increases in emissions which the state bears the brunt of being downwind of the non-RGGI states,” Baker said.
“Despite these challenges, we believe there are better paths forward for New Jersey to accomplish our shared goals of protecting consumers, supporting communities and reducing GHG emissions. We are committed to being a reliable partner in this important work.”